Client guide · Property Protection Trusts

Thinking About a Property Protection Trust?

A more detailed guide to how the arrangement works, the choices that need to be made and the questions worth considering before deciding whether it is right for you.

Why have we sent you this guide?

You may have raised the possibility of using a Property Protection Trust in your Will, or you may have come across the idea while researching ways of protecting your share of the family home.

The basic concept is fairly simple: instead of your share of the property passing outright to the surviving spouse or partner, your share can pass into a trust created by your Will.

The survivor can then be given rights to continue benefiting from the property while your share is preserved for the people you ultimately want to inherit.

The important part, however, is not simply deciding that you “want a Property Protection Trust”. The important part is deciding what you actually want the trust to achieve.

This guide is designed to help you think those questions through before we discuss the arrangement in more detail.

Start with the purpose

What are you actually trying to achieve?

A trust is a legal structure rather than an objective in itself. Starting with the outcome you want usually makes the later decisions much easier.

Begin With the Outcome, Not the Trust

People consider Property Protection Trusts for different reasons.

You may want the surviving spouse or partner to remain secure in the family home while also wanting your own share ultimately to pass to your children or other chosen beneficiaries.

This can be particularly relevant where there are children from an earlier relationship, or where you want more certainty about the eventual destination of your share of the property.

It may help to ask yourself:

  • Who do I want to protect immediately after my death?
  • Who do I ultimately want to inherit my share?
  • Do I want the survivor to own my share outright?
  • How much flexibility should the survivor have?
  • Am I mainly concerned about remarriage or changing family circumstances?
  • Am I trying to preserve an inheritance for children?
Andrew & Rosemary

Andrew and Rosemary want whichever of them survives to remain secure in their home, but they also want their respective shares eventually to pass to their children, James and Sophie.

Understand the Basic Structure

A Property Protection Trust is normally written into your Will.

It does not usually mean transferring your home into a trust while you are alive.

Instead, the relevant trust begins after your death. Your share of the property passes into the trust rather than being given outright to the surviving spouse or partner.

The survivor keeps whatever share already belongs to them and is given rights over the deceased person's share according to the terms of the trust.

Andrew & Rosemary

Their home is worth £400,000 and they each own 50%. If Andrew dies first, Rosemary keeps her own £200,000 share. Andrew's £200,000 share passes into the trust created by his Will.

The precise rights Rosemary receives over Andrew's share depend upon the wording of Andrew's Will.

Check How the Property Is Owned

Before a share of a jointly owned property can pass into a trust under a Will, that share must be capable of passing under the Will.

This is why the distinction between joint tenants and tenants in common matters.

Joint tenants: the property passes automatically to the surviving joint owner on the first death. The deceased owner's interest does not pass under their Will.

Tenants in common: each owner has a separate share. That share can pass under the terms of their Will.

A Property Protection Trust will therefore normally require the relevant beneficial ownership to be held as tenants in common.

If necessary, changing from joint tenants to tenants in common is called severance of the joint tenancy.

We can check the ownership position and discuss whether any change is required.

What Happens on the First Death?

The surviving owner does not normally lose their own share of the property.

Their existing share remains theirs.

It is the deceased person's share that is dealt with by the trust.

Andrew dies first

Rosemary continues to own her 50%. Andrew's 50% enters the trust. Rosemary can then benefit from Andrew's share in the way Andrew's Will allows, without becoming the outright owner of that share.

This distinction is central to the arrangement: the survivor can be protected without necessarily owning the deceased person's share outright.

Designing the arrangement

What should the survivor be able to do?

The survivor's rights are not an afterthought. They are one of the most important parts of designing the trust.

Think About the Survivor's Right to Remain in the Home

In many Property Protection Trust arrangements, the surviving spouse or partner is given the right to continue living in the property.

However, the exact terms matter.

Questions may include:

  • Should the survivor be entitled to stay for life?
  • Should the right end if they permanently leave the property?
  • Should remarriage or a new relationship affect the arrangement?
  • Who pays ordinary household costs?
  • Who is responsible for major repairs?
  • What happens if the property becomes unsuitable?

There is no benefit in creating a trust that protects an asset for the future but makes the survivor's everyday life unnecessarily difficult.

Should the Survivor Be Able to Move or Downsize?

A common concern is that a trust might force the survivor to remain in the original family home indefinitely.

It does not necessarily have to work that way.

The trust can be drafted to permit the property to be sold and, where appropriate, the trust's share of the proceeds used towards a replacement property.

Andrew & Rosemary

Five years after Andrew's death, Rosemary decides the family home is too large. The trust allows a sale and the purchase of a smaller property, so Rosemary can move while Andrew's trust interest remains protected.

It is worth thinking about:

  • Whether the survivor should be able to sell
  • Whether a replacement property can be purchased
  • Whether trustees must approve a move
  • What happens if the replacement property costs less
  • What happens to any surplus trust money
  • Whether the survivor may move into rented or supported accommodation

Choose the Trustees Carefully

Trustees are responsible for the share of the property held in trust and must administer it in accordance with the terms of the Will.

Depending on the circumstances, trustees may need to be involved in matters such as a sale, replacement property or the eventual distribution of the trust assets.

When considering trustees, think about:

  • Who you trust to act responsibly
  • Whether they understand the family circumstances
  • Whether they are likely to work constructively with the survivor
  • Whether there could be conflicts between trustees and beneficiaries
  • Whether the people chosen are likely to remain suitable over time
  • Whether professional input may ever be required

A trust is easier to operate when the people involved understand both the legal structure and the practical purpose behind it.

Who Should Ultimately Receive the Protected Share?

The trust needs to identify what should happen when the survivor's entitlement comes to an end.

For many couples, the eventual beneficiaries will be their children.

But that should not simply be assumed.

You may want to consider:

  • Children from the current relationship
  • Children from earlier relationships
  • Grandchildren
  • What happens if a beneficiary dies before the trust ends
  • Whether beneficiaries should inherit equally
  • Whether any beneficiary may need their own trust protection
Andrew & Rosemary

Andrew's trust provides that when Rosemary's entitlement ends, Andrew's protected share passes to James and Sophie in the proportions he has chosen.

Limits and practical issues

Understand what the trust does — and what it does not do

A Property Protection Trust can be useful, but it should not be sold as a solution to every future risk.

Be Careful With Claims About Care Fees

Property Protection Trusts are sometimes promoted online as a way of “protecting the house from care fees”.

That description is too simplistic.

Local-authority care funding involves a financial assessment and the result depends on the person's actual assets, circumstances and the rules applying at the time.

The fact that a deceased person's share is held in trust may be relevant because the survivor does not own that share outright. However, the survivor's own assets remain relevant to any future assessment.

A Property Protection Trust should not be chosen solely because somebody has promised that it will prevent care fees.

The central purpose is normally to determine what happens to the deceased person's share while balancing the survivor's security with the interests of the eventual beneficiaries.

Tell Us About Any Mortgage or Equity Release

The practical position can be more complicated where the property is subject to secured borrowing.

This could include a conventional mortgage, lifetime mortgage or another equity-release arrangement.

The existence and terms of that borrowing may affect what can happen following a death, a sale or a later move.

Please therefore tell us about any borrowing secured against the home rather than assuming that the trust can simply operate around it.

Helpful information includes:

  • The lender
  • Approximate amount outstanding
  • Whether both owners are borrowers
  • Whether the arrangement is a lifetime mortgage
  • Any known restrictions on sale or transfer
  • Whether the property is leasehold

Tax and Administration Still Matter

Creating a trust does not make tax and administration disappear.

Depending on the precise trust, the assets involved and the circumstances of the family, issues can arise involving inheritance tax, capital gains tax, income tax, trust administration and registration requirements.

This does not mean that every Property Protection Trust creates a major tax problem.

It does mean that the tax consequences should follow from the structure actually being created rather than from a generic label such as “Property Protection Trust”.

Where specialist tax advice is needed, that can be identified before the arrangement is finalised.

Information That Will Help Before We Talk

You do not need to prepare formal legal documents before the discussion.

However, where available, it is useful to know:

  • The property address
  • Approximate current value
  • Who owns the property
  • Whether you believe it is joint tenants or tenants in common
  • The shares you believe each person owns
  • Details of any mortgage or equity release
  • Who you want to protect after the first death
  • Who you ultimately want to inherit
  • Who you might choose as trustees
  • Whether either of you has children from an earlier relationship
  • Whether moving or downsizing should be permitted
  • Any particular concerns that led you to consider the trust

Do not delay a conversation because you do not know every answer.

One of the purposes of the discussion is to identify what needs checking.

Before you decide

You Do Not Need to Decide on the Trust Before We Talk

It is perfectly reasonable to begin the conversation by saying: “I have been reading about Property Protection Trusts and I think this might be what I want.”

The discussion is designed to establish:

  • What you are trying to achieve
  • How the property is owned
  • Whether a trust is actually needed
  • What the survivor should be able to do
  • Who should act as trustees
  • Who should ultimately inherit
  • Whether severance is needed
  • Whether borrowing affects the arrangement
  • Whether specialist advice is required
  • Whether a simpler Will arrangement would achieve the same goal

You are not expected to design the legal wording yourself.

The useful preparation is to think about the people involved, the outcome you want and how much flexibility the survivor should have.

An important distinction

The Name of the Trust Matters Less Than the Wording Inside Your Will

“Property Protection Trust” is a useful way of describing the planning objective, but the actual rights of the survivor, trustees and beneficiaries come from the provisions drafted into the Will.

Two couples may both say that they have a Property Protection Trust while having different arrangements for occupation, moving house, trustees, beneficiaries and the circumstances in which the trust ends.

This is why the aim is not simply to insert a standard trust clause. The aim is to create an arrangement that reflects your property, your family and the outcome you want.

Ready to Talk It Through?

If this guide reflects what you are trying to achieve, the next step is to talk through your property, family circumstances and the rights you would want the survivor to have. You do not need to arrive with the structure already worked out.